Weaving a Dynamic Net of Shared Relationships
Dear People, Neighbours, and Friends of St. Thomas’s,
Last Sunday, after a combined High Mass that gathered one hundred and forty people in the church and many more online, sixty-seven of us gathered in the parish hall and on Zoom for a special Vestry meeting about the Cornerstone Project. Seventy minutes later, the motion before us had carried unanimously. Anyone who has spent time around Anglicans knows that unanimity on any subject involving both money and architecture is not to be taken for granted, and I am deeply grateful to all the voting members of this parish and to those newcomers and friends who attended to learn more about the project and ask questions. Just before Fr. Micah dismissed us, Elizabeth Anderson led us in singing “Christ Is Our Cornerstone,” which is surely the only fitting way to end a meeting about construction financing. For those of you who could not be at the meeting in person or online, I’m happy to provide the following summary of what happened.
First, the cost. A year ago, our concept-level estimate for the project was $8.1 million. After a year of detailed design work and of testing our soil, bricks, pipes, and wiring, the estimate now stands at $11 million, including a contingency. The scope of what we are building has not changed at all: an Accessibility Atrium joining the church and parish hall, with an elevator, ramps, and a universal washroom, along with new heating and targeted cooling for the church. What has changed is how much more we know about our heritage site, the logistical challenges of inserting new construction in a narrow area between two buildings, and what labour and materials now cost. One takeaway from our meeting is that the surest way to make this project more expensive is to wait longer than we already have! Subject to the necessary approvals from the Diocese and permits from the City, we hope to break ground in March 2027.
Second, where we stand. Thanks to the generosity of parishioners and friends, $5.8 million, just over half of what we need, has been raised, pledged, or set aside from past campaigns. Vestry directed the Cornerstone Leadership Team to keep seeking the rest through gifts and pledges and through grants from foundations, corporations, and government. The campaign, in other words, is very much alive.
Third, I announced a bequest from our late parishioner Nigel Wright and explained its relationship to the current project. (See my Rector’s Letter from November 7th for further background.) I should repeat here what I said in the parish hall: that bequest is not going to build the atrium. The estate will not be settled for some years, and we do not yet know how much we will receive or when. Whenever the bequest comes, Corporation intends to invest it as an endowment for the long-term sustainability of the parish rather than spend it on construction. The Churchwardens and I would be poor stewards of Nigel’s generosity, and of yours, if we let anyone conclude that the Cornerstone Project is already paid for, or will be, from this bequest. It is not, and it will not. Nigel intended his bequest to supplement the ongoing faithful stewardship of the living. Parishes with endowments tend to learn to their sorrow that if they become complacent and depend upon the dead to be more generous than the living, an inevitable decline sets in; when people are no longer personally invested in the daily, monthly, and annual well-being of their parish, suddenly those structural deficits that the bequest was intended to close begin to widen. Thus, every pledge and every grant to the Cornerstone Campaign matters as much today as it did before the meeting, and every gift to our operating budget, adjusted for inflation, will be as necessary in 2027 as it was in 2026.
Fourth, the financing. In early 2027, construction invoices will start to arrive monthly, while campaign pledges will arrive over a number of years. How does one pay for a project that will be completed in a little over a year when it might take five years or more for all the funds raised to be received? And what about the other fifty percent of funds that remain to be raised? St. Thomas’s would be hard pressed to carry long-term debt at market rates. Vestry therefore authorized Corporation to apply to the Diocese, or to another lender the Diocese approves, for a line of credit of up to $5.2 million, drawn only as needed to cover that gap in timing, to be repaid as gifts and grants come in. As I told Bishop Kevin Robertson, seminary prepared me for a good many things, but revolving lines of credit were not among them! I am thankful that Michael Rowland presented the motion and that our wardens, treasurer, and leadership team, including Ian Taylor, have done such careful work in ensuring that we have done our due diligence in advance of going before the diocesan Risk & Governance and Finance committees.
I should be clear, however, that what Vestry approved is merely a proposal to those committees, and one we hold lightly. Under the canons, we cannot proceed, and would not wish to, without the approval of Synod Council, whose committees are responsible for stewarding resources on behalf of the whole Diocese, not just Smoky Tom’s. In Rhode Island, I served as the vice president of Diocesan Council, so I understand that Synod Council will have a much wider perspective on things than we have, with many more factors to consider. Our application to the Diocese is but one example of how we might address this timing issue in partnership, and we have tried to shape it in the spirit of the Cast the Net Calls to Action, particularly three calls concerned with transforming diocesan culture. First, Cast the Net asks us to see the Diocese as a dynamic net of shared relationships, which is why we have turned first to our own diocesan family rather than to a bank, so that rather than paying interest to an entity looking for a profit, we pay returns to the ministry of the wider Church. Our contribution to the Cast the Net capital campaign will be largely determined by what any financing plan makes possible. Second, Cast the Net asks for an integrated, theologically informed approach to property, and I can think of no sounder theology of property than one that removes any barrier keeping God’s children from the presence of the living God. Third, Cast the Net asks us to invest in the diocesan vision using sound principles of Christian stewardship, which is why we are proposing to borrow only what we need, only when we need it, and to repay it as soon as we can.
If the Diocese’s counsel is that a different arrangement than what we propose would serve everyone better, such as some combination of a grant, a partial loan, and perhaps a lender that specializes in charities to make up any difference, we would welcome it. We have only two goals: first, to begin construction on schedule so that our now $11 million project doesn’t balloon into a $15 million dollar project, and second, to be confident that we can pay each invoice as it comes due. However the Diocese guides us toward those two ends, we will gladly follow its lead. I am grateful to Bp. Robertson for his letter of support, which I read to Vestry during the meeting, and for his continued prayers, as well as to the diocesan staff and volunteers who are giving their time and consideration to how to answer the Cast the Net Calls to Action together with us.
Our mission statement describes us as an active and welcoming parish, but it is impossible to welcome someone who cannot get through the door, whether someone is here to participate in our liturgies, to rehearse with a community choir that rents our hall, to join other guests of the Friday Food Ministry for a hearty meal, to enjoy the community concerts we present, and so much more that we do as a church and community centre for people from across the GTA and beyond. So I ask three things of you: pray, give, and connect. Specifically:
Pray. Pray for the members of Synod Council and its committees as they consider our proposals, and for Corporation and the Cornerstone Leadership Team, which includes both those on the Capital Campaign Continuation Committee charged with raising the funds, and the Accessibility Atrium Working Group, charged with ensuring we get the best value for the funds we raise.
Give. If you have not yet made a pledge to the Cornerstone Campaign, or find that you are able to add to one, now is the time.
Connect. If you know of a foundation, a corporate giving program, or a granting agency that cares about accessibility, heritage, or service to the community, please tell me or any member of the leadership team. Ask whether your employer has a matching gift program. Make introductions where you have already-established relationships, and facilitate our ongoing efforts to connect with the wider Toronto community.
Together, we can cast a wide net that benefits everyone.
Yours in Christ’s service,
Nathan J.A. Humphrey+
VIII Rector